Velvet classic

Why isn’t Southside calling for Bukele?

The views expressed in this article are those of the writer and not necessarily those of Breaking Belize News.

By Nuri Muhammad:  Why is it that some of the loudest voices calling for Bukele-style policing in Belize are not coming from the very communities supposedly living at the epicenter of gang violence? Where are the mothers and fathers, the grandmothers, aunties, sisters and brothers demanding that the police descend upon their neighborhoods with overwhelming force, round up hundreds of young men and lock them away?

Could it be that the people who actually live in these communities understand something that those calling for draconian police action do not?

I have spent more than fifty years working with young people and families in Belize, much of that time in the very neighborhoods now being portrayed as war zones. I know the pain that violence has caused. I know mothers who have buried their sons, children who have lost their fathers, and families who have suffered terribly because of the actions of a relatively small number of individuals.

But I also know that the people of Southside Belize City do not live in perpetual fear of every young man standing on a street corner. These young men are their sons, brothers, nephews, cousins and grandchildren. They know who is dangerous and who is not. They know that there are bad seeds or renegades in some neighborhoods who must be dealt with, but they also know that not every neighborhood is under siege and not every young Black man is a gangster.

And there is another uncomfortable question that those advocating the Bukele model should consider. What happens when the people themselves have reason to fear those entrusted with protecting them?

On January 7, 2013, four young Black men were brutally massacred in an apartment building at the corner of Dean and Plues Streets in Belize City. Their bodies were discovered the following morning. The brutality of those killings shocked the nation. There were serious allegations and suspicions involving members of the security services, allegations that the authorities denied. Yet, more than thirteen years later, no one has been brought to justice for those murders.

I am not presenting suspicion as established fact. But how can we ignore the damage that such an unresolved atrocity does to public confidence in law enforcement? How can we demand that communities surrender more of their rights and freedoms without first addressing their concerns about accountability and justice?

Perhaps the people who live in these neighborhoods understand that giving the security forces extraordinary powers, like Bukele’s police, does not automatically translate into greater security for ordinary citizens.

Let us not misunderstand the argument. There are dangerous criminals in Belize who must be apprehended, prosecuted and punished. The people of Southside want protection from violence just as much as anybody else. But wanting protection is not the same as demanding indiscriminate arrests, prolonged detention and the suspension of fundamental rights.

Belize is not El Salvador. We do not have the same gang structures, and culture, the same history or the same social circumstances. We must stop pretending that importing another country’s methods will somehow solve problems we have failed to address for generations.

We have to inject hope into these neighborhoods, not fear.

What would happen if we invested as much energy, money and national determination into education, employment, skills development, entrepreneurship and rebuilding families as we invest in emergency policing operations? What if young people could see a future beyond unemployment, frustration, the streets and prison?

I have long advocated for a comprehensive, multipronged **25-year National Crime Prevention and Community Development Plan**, implemented in five-year cycles, with clear objectives, measurable results and continuity regardless of which political party forms the government.

Such a plan must be administered by a permanent, statutory, quasi-governmental institution, staffed by trained professionals and supported by government, the private sector, civil society and the communities themselves. It cannot be another temporary political project that disappears with the next change of minister or government. We have rolled that stone up the hill many times only to start over and over again

Crime and violence are national problems requiring a national response, not just a police response. We need effective policing, certainly, but also serious investment in the social and economic conditions that shape the lives of our young people. We need a national commitment that rises above party politics and continues for a generation.

After decades of states of emergency, police operations, arrests and promises, surely, we should be asking whether we are prepared to do something fundamentally different.

Before we impose Bukele on Southside, shouldn’t we first ask the people who live there? Or are we afraid they might tell us that Bukele is not the answer?

The post Why isn’t Southside calling for Bukele? appeared first on Belize News and Opinion on www.breakingbelizenews.com.

The views expressed in this article are those of the writer and not necessarily those of Breaking Belize News. By Nuri Muhammad:  Why is it that some of the loudest voices calling for Bukele-style policing in Belize are not coming from the very communities supposedly living at the epicenter of gang violence? Where are the
The post Why isn’t Southside calling for Bukele? appeared first on Belize News and Opinion on www.breakingbelizenews.com.

Exit mobile version