Kyiv and Washington have struck a deal that will allow the US to share profits from the mining of Ukraine’s mineral reserves. But does it mean Donald Trump is now more willing to push Russia to make peace with Ukraine?
This deal does give Trump “a personal stake” in Ukraine’s fate, but it leaves key questions unanswered, said The New York Times.
Although Ukraine’s supporters hope the agreement will at least lead Trump “to see the country as something more than a money pit and an obstacle to improved relations” with Vladimir Putin, it will only kick in after fighting with Russia stops. And there is “no indication” that it gives Ukraine “any explicit American security guarantees against future Russian aggression”, said Lisa Haseldine in The Spectator.
What did the commentators say?
For months, Trump has been “bullying” Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy, “blaming him for the war”, while playing nice with Putin, said Jamie Dettmer at Politico. Then, last week, Trump threatened Russia with more sanctions and posted “Vladimir, STOP!” on Truth Social: was this “rare public rebuke of Putin” a sign of a key “shift” in US thinking?
A “frustrated” White House is becoming increasingly unsure of Putin’s “willingness to end the war”, said Shelby Magid at the New Atlanticist. And the minerals deal now signals US commitment to a “free, sovereign Ukraine”, which completely “undercuts” the Kremlin’s aims. Ukraine is now “in its strongest position” with Washington “since Trump took office”.
Ukraine’s “fragile new confidence” is not centred on the belief that Trump “is about to deliver peace for the ages”, said The Economist. “Rather it comes from a shift in mood – a sense that the American president may finally have got Vladimir Putin’s number” and might even “have begun to respect his Ukrainian counterpart.”
And yet, over the course of “his entire political life, Trump has never truly stood up to” Putin, said Jonathan Lemire in The Atlantic. Recently, “perhaps fearing that he’s being humiliated”, the US president has “started to show glimpses of exasperation”. But few White House insiders have any sense of when or if he might take a stand and, even if he does, he’s unlikely to truly “excoriate Putin”.
What next?
The minerals deal allows Ukraine to retain control over its natural resources, and its share of any profits “will be reinvested in post-war rebuilding”, said The New York Times. But Zelenskyy “has made clear that the minerals agreement is not an end in itself”. For him, signing the deal helps clear the way “to more consequential talks” on US military support and, ultimately, a ceasefire.
Trump has said he will now give Russia and Ukraine “two weeks or so to come to the negotiating table” to work out a peace deal, said The Spectator’s Lisa Haseldine.
Ukraine will be pulling out all the stops to show Trump that “when the clock runs out on that fortnight and fighting continues, it is Moscow – not Kyiv – who’s to blame”.
US shows ‘exasperation’ with Russia and signs agreement with Ukraine in what could be a significant shift in the search for peace
