When is your local newspaper not your local newspaper? When it’s actually a Russian disinformation operation. The New York Times said many “local” sites have popped up in recent weeks — bearing names like the New York News Daily, the Chicago Chronicle and the Miami Chronicle — that are “meant to mimic actual news organizations to push Kremlin propaganda.” The fake news sites are a “technological leap” in the ongoing campaign to “dupe unsuspecting American readers.”
It’s not just happening in the United States. The Times report came a few weeks after France discovered a “vast network of Russian disinformation sites” operating in Europe, Le Monde said. The network of nearly 200 sites — called “Portal Kombat” by investigators — is “entirely dedicated to republishing and amplifying pro-Russian propaganda.” The good news: “The audience for these sites seems very limited.”
Back in America, though, the rise of Russian news sites runs headlong into the decline of local news sources. The Conversation said the country lost more than 130 print newspapers in 2023 — and nearly 2,900 newspapers have closed since 2005. That leaves “thousands of communities that simply do not have access to local news.” Propaganda sites might be helping fill the vacuum.
‘Divide and conquer’
“Chaos and disorder is the goal,” Stew Magnuson said at National Defense. Russia appears to be “actively looking for communities where newspapers have disappeared” to fill the vacuum with propaganda campaigns meant to “erode our confidence in democratic institutions.” If so, the Russians have picked an easy target. “Newsrooms are being gutted” even in communities where local news organizations continue to operate. That leaves those communities relatively defenseless. “Divide and conquer is the strategy.”
Research shows that the “decline of local journalism is associated with the drivers of disinformation,” Jon Bateman and Dean Jackson said at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. That decline “contributes to civic ignorance and apathy” among voters, while “lower-quality information sources can fill the gap” for people looking for news. That breeds a “susceptibility to disinformation.” And that will be a big challenge to change. “Reversing the decline of local journalism is an extremely costly proposition.”
Bad actors are taking advantage. “Russia’s 2024 election interference has already begun,” NBC News said. While there are concerns about “deep fake” videos and audio entering the information ecosystem, the truth is that most of what Russia is doing is amplifying existing divisions — highlighting disagreements about immigration, for example. “They see whatever narrative is rising to the top,” said one expert, and “they try to push it.”
‘Faux local news’
“It’s easy to create a website that looks legitimate,” Poynter said. Stories from Russia’s RT news service have been found at sites like Little Rock AR News and Albuquerque Breaking News, both parts of a network of “regional sites, national sites and faux local news sites targeting specific cities in the U.S.” Sites like The Disinformation Laundromat can help news consumers distinguish between real information and propaganda. But the problem will probably get worse, said information manipulation expert Peter Benzoni. “I think you’re gonna see a huge increase in the types of people using these dissemination networks.”
The latest spate of Russia-sponsored local news sites give “the impression of topicality” with regular updates about national news, The New York Times said, but they aren’t really trying to fool “discerning” readers. (One site’s “about” page is filled with “Lorum ipsum” dummy text.) Darren Linvill of Clemson University’s Media Forensics Hub said the idea is to “lend an aura of credibility” to the disinformation, helping it spread more easily to thousands, “even millions” of readers. It’s “cheap, highly targeted and obviously effective.”
Fake news sites spread propaganda while real newspapers die
